Insurance Bad Faith Claims in Sarasota, FL

When you file an insurance claim after an accident, illness, or property loss, you have a reasonable expectation that your insurer will handle it fairly and promptly. Florida law imposes strict duties on insurance companies to do exactly that. When an insurer fails those duties — delaying payment without cause, undervaluing a claim, or outright denying valid coverage — the conduct may constitute insurance bad faith, and Florida law gives policyholders powerful remedies.

Sarasota residents dealing with difficult insurers should understand their rights under Florida's bad faith statutes and what steps to take when an insurance company acts improperly.

What Is Insurance Bad Faith Under Florida Law?

Florida recognizes two distinct forms of insurance bad faith: first-party bad faith and third-party bad faith.

First-party bad faith arises when your own insurer — the company you pay premiums to — improperly handles your claim. This includes situations where an insurer denies a valid claim, stalls unnecessarily, pays far less than the claim is worth, or fails to conduct a proper investigation.

Third-party bad faith occurs when a liability insurer fails to reasonably settle a claim against its policyholder. For example, if you are injured by a negligent driver and that driver's insurer refuses a reasonable settlement within policy limits — exposing the driver to an excess judgment — the insurer may have acted in bad faith toward its own insured.

Florida Statutes §624.155 is the primary statute governing first-party bad faith claims. It allows policyholders to sue insurers who do not attempt in good faith to settle claims when, under the circumstances, it could and should have done so. Florida also recognizes common law bad faith claims under certain circumstances.

Common Bad Faith Insurance Practices in Sarasota

Sarasota's mix of homeowners, auto, and health insurance claims means bad faith issues arise across many policy types. Insurers engage in bad faith through a wide range of conduct, including:

• Denying a claim without a reasonable basis or adequate investigation
• Failing to acknowledge or respond to a claim within a reasonable time
• Misrepresenting policy terms or coverage limits to reduce a payout
• Offering a settlement far below the documented value of a claim
• Requiring excessive or duplicative documentation to wear down claimants
• Unreasonably delaying payment after a claim has been approved
• Failing to properly communicate with the policyholder about the claim status
• Using biased experts or adjusters to undervalue property damage or injuries

In Southwest Florida, property insurance bad faith claims have increased significantly following hurricane seasons. Insurers sometimes lowball wind and water damage claims or dispute causation to avoid paying full policy benefits — conduct that can give rise to a bad faith lawsuit.

The Civil Remedy Notice: A Required Step Before Filing Suit

Florida law requires a specific procedural step before a policyholder can sue an insurer for bad faith under §624.155. You must file a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) with the Florida Department of Financial Services, with a copy sent to the insurer.

The CRN must identify the specific statutory violations and describe the facts underlying the bad faith conduct. Once the notice is filed, the insurer has 60 days to cure the violation — meaning it must pay the full amount owed under the policy or otherwise remedy the problem. If the insurer cures the violation within that window, the bad faith claim is extinguished. If it does not, the policyholder may proceed to file a lawsuit.

This notice requirement makes timing critical. Filing a CRN prematurely or without sufficient factual detail can undermine your case. An experienced attorney can help you draft an effective notice and document the insurer's ongoing failures during the cure period.

Damages Available in a Florida Bad Faith Case

One of the most significant aspects of Florida's bad faith law is the range of damages a successful claimant can recover. Unlike a standard breach of contract claim — which is typically limited to the policy benefits owed — a bad faith lawsuit can result in substantially greater compensation.

Available damages in a Florida bad faith case may include:

• The full amount of the original insurance claim, if not already paid
• Consequential damages caused by the insurer's delay or denial, such as financial hardship or additional property deterioration
• Attorney's fees and court costs, which are recoverable under Florida Statute §624.155
• Punitive damages, in cases involving particularly egregious or intentional misconduct

The potential for attorney's fees and punitive damages creates meaningful accountability for insurers and gives policyholders access to legal representation even when the original claim amount is modest.

What Sarasota Policyholders Should Do When They Suspect Bad Faith

If you believe your insurance company is mishandling your claim, taking the right steps early can protect your rights and strengthen any future legal action.

• Document everything. Keep records of every communication with your insurer — phone calls, emails, letters, and claim correspondence. Note dates, times, and the name of every representative you speak with.
• Get the denial or delay in writing. If your claim is denied or delayed, request a written explanation stating the specific reasons and the policy provisions the insurer is relying on.
• Preserve evidence of your loss. Photograph property damage, retain medical records, and save all receipts related to your claim. Do not allow an insurer's adjuster to be your only source of documentation.
• Request a copy of your policy. Insurers are legally required to provide a copy upon request. Review the declarations page, exclusions, and any endorsements carefully.
• Consult an attorney before accepting a settlement. Once you accept a settlement and sign a release, your ability to pursue further claims is typically extinguished. An attorney can evaluate whether an offer is fair before you sign.

Florida law also requires insurers to acknowledge receipt of a claim within 14 days and to begin an investigation promptly. For homeowners' claims, insurers generally must pay or deny within 90 days after receiving proof of loss. Missing these deadlines can itself be evidence of bad faith.

Sarasota policyholders dealing with hurricane damage, auto accident claims, or denied health benefits have legal tools available to hold insurers accountable. Florida's bad faith statutes exist precisely because the legislature recognized the inherent power imbalance between individual claimants and large insurance corporations. When an insurer exploits that imbalance, the law provides a meaningful remedy.

Need Help? If you have questions about your case, call or text 833-657-4812 for a free consultation with an experienced attorney.

Related Articles

• Insurance Delay Tactics in Florida Bad Faith Claims
• Wind Damage Claim Denied in Hollywood, FL
• Hollywood Water Damage Lawyer: Protect Your Claim